Mr. Miltenberg’s complaint lists Emma’s contradictions: "There were no witnesses to Emma’s alleged screams in the badly soundproofed student dorm. There was no medical report, even though an attack as massive as described would with great likelihood have caused serious injuries in dire need of medical attention. There was no testimony from Emma’s friends or family members who could confirm such injuries or changes in her behavior. On the contrary, in the days following the alleged attack, Emma participated in various social events on campus. There were varying accounts by Emma as to whether and when she had spoken to anyone about the alleged assault. Paul was able to present numerous love messages that Emma wrote to him before and after the alleged event with no apparent change in mood. Even though these messages were excluded as exculpatory evidence from the investigation, Columbia was informed about their existence and content. Columbia was also informed that Emma had a history of alleging of sexual assault. These messages, too, were excluded from evidence. These are Facebook messages that DIE ZEIT has and has partially published. On June 26, 2012, Emma wrote to Paul: "Ahhh Paul I miss you so much," and that when she was high at a party she had sex with a friend and his buddies. On Aug. 29, 2012, two days after the alleged rape, she wrote she wanted to see Paul. "We still haven’t really had a paul-emma chill sesh since summmmerrrr." And on Oct. 4 she wrote: "I love you Paul. Where are you!?!?!?!?!" " (...) Emma confirmed that the messages were authentic when asked by DIE ZEIT for her version of the story, but she did not give a reaction. Her father, Kerry Sulkowicz, a well-known psychoanalyst, also did not want to comment.
